re: Matthew Baldwin enters transfer portal

quote:

---

Smart didnt let him throw the ball because he sucked.

---

When did Smart tell you that? And you honestly believe this 5 star QB, with one of the highest ratings ever for a QB, can't throw the ball and sucks? Yet the facts show that although "Smart did't let him throw", he completed 27 of 39 passes for 329 yards, 4TDs, 0 Ints and a 69.2 completion percentage. His QB rating was 173.7.

Since you said Miles Brennan will be LSU's starter, you obviously feel he is a better QB than Fields, right? Therefore you must feel he can pass, right? He doesn't suck right? So how are you coming up with Fields can't throw and Miles can? Fields sucks but Miles doesn't. What is you conclusions based on? Surely not their college results? Mile's freshman numbers? He completed 14 0f 24 passes for 182 yards, 1 TD, 2 Ints and a 58.3 completion percentage. His QB rating was 119.1. So it couldn't be based on college. By the way do you believe O didn't let Brennan throw the ball because he sucked?

Come on man! What do you have against Fields? Everything I have read about him is he is an excellent QB. He just happened to be behind an all SEC type QB who led his team to an SEC East title and the playoffs championship as a freshman. Miles wasn't.

You remind me of the guy I had a debate with early in the season last year about Kyler Murray and Will Grier. He was claiming Grier was a much better QB than Murray. That he wasn't impressed with Murray. Well the rest is history. Murray led his team to the playoffs, won the Heisman and was the first player taken in the NFL draft. Grier? WV went 8-4 and he was selected in the 3rd round of the draft, the 5th QB selected.