Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

Bon Ton Cafe Will Now Be Bon Ton Prime Rib

Posted on 10/31/24 at 1:22 pm
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 1:22 pm
Here's the Nola.com link, but it's behind a paywall. I was able to pull it up using some archive site.

Nola.com

The Bon Ton Café has a history going back to 1877 that spans several distinct chapters. The one New Orleans knew for close to 70 years ended early in 2020, just before the pandemic, when its owners retired and the Bon Ton closed.
Very soon though, the restaurant will reopen for its next chapter with new owners, a new name and a new direction.
The restaurant is now called Bon Ton Prime Rib, and it is slated to open in mid to late November.

It will be a new restaurant in the same address at 401 Magazine St. Some of the dishes for which Bon Ton Café was known will return, as will the old restaurant’s signature cocktail, the Rum Ramsey.
But one of the big changes is referenced right in the new name Bon Ton Prime Rib.
The new menu will be a blend of Cajun flavor from the Bon Ton past with steaks that are the specialty of its new owners.
“Everyone knows the Bon Ton, so we wanted to start with that good will and feature what we do well,” said Jerry Greenbaum, co-founder of the restaurant group CentraArchy, which created Bon Ton Prime Rib.
“This is not your father’s Bon Ton, or your great, great grandfather’s Bon Ton, because that’s how far back it goes.” Greenbaum said. “This is new.”
Cajun flavor, prime cuts
CentraArchy is a Charleston, S.C.-based company that has 14 restaurants across the southeast, including one in New Orleans, the steak house Chophouse, which is just across the street from Bon Ton Prime Rib.

The marquee dish at the new restaurant will be prime prime rib – that is, prime rib cut from prime grade beef. Greenbaum calls this dish the key to the whole restaurant (more on this below).
Elsewhere on the new menu, there are conventional steakhouse cuts and an array of Cajun dishes inspired by the restaurant’s past. That includes crabmeat au gratin, an etouffee (now made with crawfish, shrimp and crabmeat together), bisque, crab cakes and snapper roasted with Cajun seasoned butter (see a draft of the opening menu below).

The restaurant was first opened in 1877 just down the street, at 308 Magazine St. That makes the Bon Ton the third-oldest restaurant in New Orleans, behind Antoine's and Tujague's, though it changed a great deal through successive owners. It moved twice, first to 322 Magazine St. (which, coincidentally, is the address now occupied by Chophouse) and finally to its present home.
Today’s incarnation took shape between those moves. In 1953 it was acquired by the Alzina and Al Pierce, who hailed from the bayou country around Houma. They installed a menu of dishes from that region, which was a major departure from the French Creole standard of New Orleans. The Bon Ton became an early outpost for Cajun cooking in the city.

The family owners’ next generation, Debbie and Wayne Pierce, later took over and ran the Bon Ton for decades, adhering to traditional and even old fashioned ways.
Meanwhile, Greenbaum’s company opened Chophouse in 2011, in what had been the restaurant Cuvee. Greenbaum said he’d been looking for another location in New Orleans ever since, and always admired his neighbors at the Bon Ton. When the Pierce family was ready to retire, he saw an opportunity and offered to buy the property.
“I’ve always loved the Bon Ton, the building is gorgeous and it has such a history,” he said.

He has close ties to New Orleans. He and his wife Barbara met while attending Tulane University and they visited frequently ever since graduating (class of 1962). The same year Chophouse opened, Greenbaum joined Tulane’s board of trustees, bringing him to New Orleans even more.
What’s new now
The plan to buy Bon Ton was in the works when the pandemic arrived and upended all restaurant plans. A renovation eventually got under way and reopening was imminent in September 2023 when a fire broke out, forcing a complete redo. But Greenbaum pressed ahead.

Today, the restaurant has been reconfigured once again with the deep booths in the center of the room and around the perimeter, and a much larger bar, now moved across the room near the entrance.
Bare brick walls, iron columns, exposed beams and windows with louvered shutters topped with half-circle transoms all evoke the past here.
The prime prime rib is central to the new menu. It will be served in two sizes (a 12 oz. regular cut and “the Bon Ton Cut,” at over 30 oz.), but in only one temperature, medium rare. The restaurant will also have a reservation system specifically for the Bon Ton Cut, so customers can reserve one when booking a table to ensure its availability.
Bon Ton Prime Rib will serve dinner only, another change from the old Bon Ton, which was known for lunch, and will open on weekends, when the former restaurant traditionally closed.
Bon Ton Prime Rib
401 Magazine St.
Projected opening: mid-November 2024

Menu

Here's a picture of the inside. I don't like it.



I have no interest in prime rib when I go to New Orleans to eat. I'll be looking to see if the crab au gratin is the same. I might go if it is, but Galatoire's is also very good. No more crawfish bisque is really disappointing. Why would I order a Cajun bacon appetizer before my dinner meal? I wouldn't. Actually, most of the menu is disappointing. I was hoping they would keep much of the old menu and just add to it with what else they wanted to offer. They really took off some favorites. There is NO bread pudding listed under desserts!

Posted by Fun Bunch
New Orleans
Member since May 2008
123423 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 1:23 pm to
For some reason I never made it to Bon Ton. Just never was on my radar and never made it there
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 1:38 pm to
quote:

For some reason I never made it to Bon Ton. Just never was on my radar and never made it there


When I lived in New Orleans and worked downtown, we ate lunch there frequently and sometimes dinner after working late. After I moved away, I've been back a number of times on my visits.

It's just darn fine food. It's was never eclectic, but food was always fresh and of great quality. It was consistent every time. The crabmeat was always huge lumps. The crawfish bisque was some of the best I've ever had and I love a good crawfish bisque. Lots of good fish dishes as well. Staff and service was always great. Place was pretty much packed all the time. Many times there were lines of people waiting at lunch. It may not have been your cup of tea. I loved the place. I'm very sad.
Posted by Pettifogger
I don't really care, Margaret
Member since Feb 2012
83262 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 1:43 pm to
Opening a prime steakhouse across the street from your own flagship prime steakhouse is...interesting
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 1:47 pm to
quote:

Opening a prime steakhouse across the street from your own flagship prime steakhouse is...interesting


No doubt.
Posted by geauxpurple
New Orleans
Member since Jul 2014
14722 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 3:18 pm to
Do we really need to transform an old historic New Orleans classic into a prime rib restaurant?
Posted by Y.A. Tittle
Member since Sep 2003
107204 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 3:49 pm to
quote:

I have no interest in prime rib when I go to New Orleans to eat.


The whole thing sounds like a head scratching business decision.

Bon Ton was a wonderful throwback sort of place. All the old federal judges loved it.

New Orleans has one restaurant known for prime rib. It's perfectly adequate for anyone who would possibly need to fulfill and itch to get that. I can't imagine why it would ever need two, especially one that's also trying to still cling to some sort of "cajun" character of the place it took over.
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 4:09 pm to
quote:

The whole thing sounds like a head scratching business decision.


So true. I just don't get it at all and also across the street from a steakhouse they already own.

quote:

Bon Ton was a wonderful throwback sort of place. All the old federal judges loved it.


Lunch during the week was like a meeting place. It always seemed like most people there knew each other.

quote:

New Orleans has one restaurant known for prime rib. It's perfectly adequate for anyone who would possibly need to fulfill and itch to get that. I can't imagine why it would ever need two, especially one that's also trying to still cling to some sort of "cajun" character of the place it took over.


There's not much Cajun left to it. I just don't get it. It was very much a locals place in my mind. I don't see a lot of locals heading there for prime rib. Tourists aren't usually looking for prime rib. It was one of the few places left with some good Cajun offerings as well, so it was somewhat unique in that regard and for tourists erroneously looking for Cajun fare in New Orleans. This was the place once K-Paul's was gone.
Posted by OTIS2
NoLA
Member since Jul 2008
51391 posts
Posted on 10/31/24 at 4:54 pm to
I got there a few weeks before it closed. It was a very nice place.
Posted by IggyReilly
New Orleans, LA
Member since Dec 2015
132 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 8:12 am to
quote:

Opening a prime steakhouse across the street from your own flagship prime steakhouse is...interesting


I don't want to be the person who's too negative about a place before it opens, but I'm having a hard time seeing what they're going for exactly. They kept the old name (sort of), but the new menu and decor have very little to do with the old restaurant. The pictures of the new decor are uninspiring to say the least. For a location with such a rich history, why go with a setting that seems so generic and cookie cutter?

As for the menu, I really don't know what to say. I'm glad they're offering prime rib (I LOVE prime rib), but I'm not sure making it the focal point of your restaurant is the wisest move in New Orleans. People who are in the mood for steak are likely to go elsewhere (probably across the street to Chophouse) and people who are in the mood for Cajun/Creole are likely go elsewhere also. I guess they'll capture 100% of the prime rib market that doesn't want to go to Rib Room, but how many people is that going to be on a regular basis exactly?

But, they're the successful restaurateurs and I don't know anything more about restaurants other than eating in them so what do I know? I'll probably give them a shot next time I'm in the mood for prime rib (whenever that is).
Posted by redfish99
B.R.
Member since Aug 2007
17659 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 10:56 am to
Damn glad it’s reopening but yea the decor and menu not at all to my liking.. I brought tons of customers and principals there during conventions. Will prob give it try next time down there. I do like Prime Rib.
Posted by Willie Stroker
Member since Sep 2008
14446 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 10:58 am to
Seems like we need to go and just order the old menu items and NOT get the prime rib.

If this becomes the customer norm, they will get the message. Maybe.
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 11:53 am to
quote:

Damn glad it’s reopening but yea the decor and menu not at all to my liking..


I don't get the decor at all. They ruined the ambiance and the feel of the historic building. I don't like booths like that at all. If you have 4 people, at least two of them are having to slide in and out. If you're on the end and someone on the inside needs to get up, you have to get up and let them slide out and then get up again when they return and let them slide back in.
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 11:54 am to
quote:

Seems like we need to go and just order the old menu items and NOT get the prime rib.

If this becomes the customer norm, they will get the message. Maybe.


Sadly, there's not much of the old menu left.
Posted by Righteous Dude
Member since Oct 2017
1449 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 3:23 pm to
quote:

There is NO bread pudding listed under desserts!



This is disappointing although there is no guarantee it would be as good as the original if they had it.
Posted by Gris Gris
OTIS!NO RULES FOR SAUCES ON STEAK!!
Member since Feb 2008
49028 posts
Posted on 11/1/24 at 4:04 pm to
quote:

This is disappointing although there is no guarantee it would be as good as the original if they had it.


I believe they bought the business as well as the building, so you'd think they could make it as Bon Ton did.
Posted by IH8ThreePutts
Member since Mar 2018
1669 posts
Posted on 11/2/24 at 2:37 pm to
If Ms. Joy doesn’t come back it’s a hard pass for me

Same thing with the salty old blonde bartender, think Lisa was her name.
Posted by LSU Tiger Bob
South
Member since Sep 2011
3074 posts
Posted on 11/2/24 at 3:45 pm to
Out of business before they open!
Posted by SlidellCajun
Slidell la
Member since May 2019
13471 posts
Posted on 11/2/24 at 4:25 pm to
Bon ton was one of my favorite spots downtown

I’d take people from out of town and they loved it. Not your typical nola spot but really good and great service
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram