Started By
Message

Wooden pergola instead of an aluminum patio cover

Posted on 10/2/20 at 4:08 am
Posted by ChewyDante
Member since Jan 2007
17022 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 4:08 am
So I am currently debating whether to go with a wooden pergola set up with a translucent cover or an aluminum patio cover.

I am leaning towards the pergola on account of price and I would like to permit light into this space. I also like the aesthetic options.

My question generally is, what are the biggest tradeoffs or cons to getting a pergola as opposed to a more traditional aluminum patio cover?
Posted by HarryCallahan
Member since Sep 2015
152 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 5:10 am to
The only drawback to the pergola is the maintenance of the wood. Not sure what kind of wood you will be using. Redwood, cedar, a tropical hardwood, PTP? It would be beneficial to use a tropical hardwood due to the extreme exposure the pergola will have with the elements. But then-you run into high wood price for materials. While PTP is ideal price wise-it will twist and warp as it dries. Just my thoughts. Aluminum patio covers are a solid choice but don’t offer the benefit of “open air” or a more natural setting it sounds like you are looking for.
Posted by TheBoo
South to Louisiana
Member since Aug 2012
5089 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 9:09 am to
Had a few friends build pergolas in the past few years out of heavy cedar. Both covered them with corrugated aluminum to make it a patio.

Sealed cedar will last a long, long time, helps repel insects, and is gorgeous.
Posted by BlackPot
Member since Oct 2016
2365 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 10:07 am to
Pergolas are cool until you realize you live in Louisiana and you want shade. I went with a aluminum top. My sister and BIL have built a couple homes and put pergolas. Each time after a few months, they slap some metal up there.
Posted by RaginCajunz
Member since Mar 2009
6549 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 10:41 am to
Can you source cedar beams from local lumber yards?

I'm interested in building a pavilion and am debating lumber options. Cypress is available with a wait. I'd be interested in cedar if it were available in 6x6s and at least 12' long. I should call around, but figured it's easy enough to ask here.
Posted by ChewyDante
Member since Jan 2007
17022 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 10:21 pm to
My limited research thus far does indicate cedar to be the ideal wood choice. I am interested to know if anyone has first hand experience with what kind of maintenance is necessary to preserve the wood. I would like to go with a stain over paint.

I'm also looking to add the translucent pergola covers made out of polycarbonate. Also curious as to cleaning/maintenance routine to keep those clean and mildew free.
Posted by Hammond Tiger Fan
Hammond
Member since Oct 2007
16352 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 10:24 pm to
I was faced with this decision when designing my outdoor kitchen space. I chose an insulated aluminum cover because of rain and the intense heat during the summer months. I haven't had any regrets.
Posted by ChewyDante
Member since Jan 2007
17022 posts
Posted on 10/2/20 at 11:46 pm to
A driving factor in favor of the pergola option for me is that the structure will go over the primary light source for my living area. I am definitely trading off the cooling advantages of an aluminum patio but I feel like with the polycarbonate covers I can let in light and still at least cut down on the heat.
Posted by TheBoo
South to Louisiana
Member since Aug 2012
5089 posts
Posted on 10/4/20 at 1:23 am to
Cedar is naturally resistant to rot, but will turn grey over time. A sealant preserves the wood much longer. You'll need to put several generous coats as it will soak up a large amount. One of the builds mentioned in my above post was done this way a few years ago and it still looks like the day we finished it, granted it's covered and only sees partial sun.

Personally the look of clear sealed cedar is hard to beat and won't fade like a stain will if exposed to the sun. My cedar fence is sealed with a walnut stain sealant and after 4 years it's faded pretty good where it takes full sun.

As for the polycarbonate, a pressure washer and some Jomax/bleach should work fine. If it's translucent then cleaning the top would be the biggest challenge.
Posted by i am dan
NC
Member since Aug 2011
28092 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 6:41 am to
I am having the same debate. One thing I've heard that I didn't think about was that birds will land on pergolas and crap on stuff. Just a thought.

I still like pergolas more though.
Posted by Chucktown_Badger
The banks of the Ashley River
Member since May 2013
33785 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 10:15 am to
I've seen pergolas that have a pulley system with a tarp or shade that you can extend out over the top or pulley it back. Could be best of both worlds.
Posted by Mr. Hangover
New Orleans
Member since Sep 2003
34766 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 2:03 pm to
I just don’t understand the appeal of building a pergola in south Louisiana. They offer little to no shade and when it rains, no cover from the elements


All that, combined with the price on wood at the moment, would make me want to build an aluminum patio. I just put up a 13x22 aluminum patio by myself (a buddy helped). The materials only cost me $1200
Posted by LSU4ever2002
Member since Sep 2009
659 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 2:24 pm to
quote:

I just put up a 13x22 aluminum patio by myself (a buddy helped). The materials only cost me $1200


Got any pictures? I have a slab in my backyard im looking to cover. Wife wants a pavilion, but looking into cheaper options.
Posted by Mr. Hangover
New Orleans
Member since Sep 2003
34766 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 2:36 pm to
Post your email here and I’ll send you some when I get home this evening
Posted by LSU4ever2002
Member since Sep 2009
659 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 3:11 pm to
tbour17@gmail.com

Thanks.
Posted by BMoney
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2005
16641 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 3:51 pm to
quote:

Pergolas are cool until you realize you live in Louisiana and you want shade. I went with a aluminum top. My sister and BIL have built a couple homes and put pergolas. Each time after a few months, they slap some metal up there.


This. I built a pergola-style patio cover with translucent fiberglass panels because I wanted a cover, but with some light let it. It sounded great in theory, but ended up just turning into a greenhouse.

When I put up a new roof this spring, I had to take the pergola cover down. Replaced it with an aluminum patio cover (16x14) that's tied into my gutters and does a much better job of keeping the temps down. Was also able to wire in a ceiling fan that really makes it nice.

Cost me $1,200 to have it installed, and I don't think I'd save much more by building another wood pergola one.
Posted by Mr. Hangover
New Orleans
Member since Sep 2003
34766 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 8:38 pm to
Didn’t get home til late. I’ll take some pics and send you some tomorrow
Posted by ChewyDante
Member since Jan 2007
17022 posts
Posted on 10/5/20 at 11:40 pm to
quote:

I just don’t understand the appeal of building a pergola in south Louisiana. They offer little to no shade and when it rains, no cover from the elements



Well I agree in respect to a pergola with no cover. But I'm potentially interested in a pergola with a translucent polycarbonate cover. From my research there are a few different variations but I'm interested in one that would let in about 30% of the light. The goal would be to have a little bit of both worlds in allowing in light but also generating some shade and a cover. I've only got the three windows along the backside of my living area that would all be blocked out by a standard patio cover. Great for reducing energy costs but it would kill any natural light into my living space.
Posted by slapahoe
USA
Member since Sep 2009
7469 posts
Posted on 10/6/20 at 11:15 am to
Interested in this topic also. I'm looking to add some cover to the back of my house. I was debating doing a pergola with aluminum top attached to my house or not attached but overhanging my roofline. The back of my house is shaped like a ' U '
Posted by AllsGroovn
Metairie, LA
Member since Jun 2005
1958 posts
Posted on 10/6/20 at 12:31 pm to
https://sequoiaoutdoorsupply.com/pergola-kits

Sequoia Outdoor Supply in Metairie - They helped design a customer pergola with roof. I bought cedar from them and had French Quarter Fencing do install.

They have great photos on the website, might give you a few ideas.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram