Most stacked MLB All-Star Game lineups of all-time

What were some of the best All-Star game lineups in history? Here are some of the favorites from the ones I looked up.

1934 AL All-Stars

1. Charlie Gehringer 2B
2. Heinie Manush LF
3. Babe Ruth RF
4. Lou Gehrig 1B
5. Jimmie Foxx 3B
6. Al Simmons CF
7. Joe Cronin SS
8. Bill Dickey C
9. Lefty Gomez P

Every player in the lineup went on to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

1965 NL All-Stars

1. Willie Mays CF
2. Hank Aaron RF
3. Willie Stargell LF
4. Dick Allen 3B
5. Joe Torre C
6. Ernie Banks 1B
7. Pete Rose 2B
8. Maury Wills SS
9. Juan Marichal P

Star power at the top is hard to top along with Banks, Rose and Marichal makes this lineup one of the all-time greats.

1973 NL All-Stars
1. Joe Morgan 2B
2. Willie Mays CF
3. Hank Aaron RF
4. Willie Stargell LF
5. Johnny Bench C
6. Lee May 1B
7. Joe Torre 3B
8. Don Kessinger SS
9. Bob Gibson P

Starts to thin out towards the end but it's hard to find a better top five than this one.

1985 AL All-Stars
1. Rickey Henderson CF
2. Lou Whitaker 2B
3. George Brett 3B
4. Eddie Murray 1B
5. Cal Ripken SS
6. Dave Winfield RF
7. Jim Rice LF
8. Carlton Fisk C
9. Jack Morris P

Seven Hall of Famers along with Jack Morris and the criminally underrated Lou Whitaker.


1994 AL All-Stars
1. Roberto Alomar 2B
2. Wade Boggs 3B
3. Ken Griffey CF
4. Frank Thomas 1B
5. Joe Carter LF
6. Kirby Puckett RF
7. Cal Ripken SS
8. Ivan Rodriguez C
9. Jimmy Key P

The AL had some great all-star game lineups in the '90s.

1995 AL All-Stars
1. Kenny Lofton CF
2. Carlos Baerga 2B
3. Edgar Martinez DH
4. Frank Thomas 1B
5. Albert Belle LF
6. Cal Ripken SS
7. Wade Boggs 3B
8. Kirby Puckett RF
9. Ivan Rodriguez C

Prime Edgar Martinez, Frank Thomas and Albert Belle in the middle of lineup. Yeesh.

1998 NL All-Stars
1. Craig Biggio 2B
2. Tony Gwynn RF
3. Mark McGwire 1B
4. Barry Bonds LF
5. Chipper Jones 3B
6. Mike Piazza C
7. Larry Walker CF
8. Walt Weiss SS
9. Greg Maddux P

Is it safe to say that Walt Weiss sticks out like a sore thumb in this lineup?

1999 NL All-Stars
1. Barry Larkin SS
2. Larry Walker RF
3. Sammy Sosa CF
4. Mark McGwire 1B
5. Matt Williams 3B
6. Jeff Bagwell DH
7. Mike Piazza C
8. Jeromy Burnitz LF
9. Jay Bell 2B

And to think Pedro Martinez struck out five of the first six hitters in this game. Amazing stuff.

1999 AL All-Stars
1. Kenny Lofton LF
2. Nomar Garciaparra SS
3. Ken Griffey CF
4. Manny Ramirez RF
5. Jim Thome 1B
6. Cal Ripken 3B
7. Rafael Palmeiro DH
8. Ivan Rodriguez C
9. Roberto Alomar 2B

The NL lineup got a lot of hubbub but the AL was pretty stacked in their own right.

2004 AL All-Stars
1. Ichiro Suzuki CF
2. Ivan Rodriguez C
3. Vladimir Guerrero RF
4. Manny Ramirez LF
5. Alex Rodriguez 3B
6. Jason Giambi 1B
7. Derek Jeter SS
8. Alfonso Soriano 2B
9. Mark Mulder P

The best All-Star game lineup in the last ten years.