I see the Saints QB situation like this….

quote:

---

wait a year then we will be able to afford a really nice house ( better QB options in 2026).

---

By restructuring Carr’s deal a few weeks back we will be even more f*cked next year than we are this year. The restructuring essentially has pushed back any hopes of getting rid of Carr at least another 2 to 3 years. Using your “nice house” analogy, we will be living in a rundown shack in the Lowa Nint Ward for the foreseeable future. Thanks, frickhead Loomis.

quote:

---

Just draft Dart. It’s not difficult.

---

Where? At 9? What if he busts?

quote:

---

By restructuring Carr’s deal a few weeks back we will be even more f*cked next year than we are this year. The restructuring essentially has pushed back any hopes of getting rid of Carr at least another 2 to 3 years. 

---

This is false.

quote:

---

This is universally considered a weak QB draft.

---

I feel like this statement is overblown. The reason this draft is considered so weak is because there is not a definitive #1, or a QB that is considered a generational talent. There also are concerns about the depth of talent at the QB position this draft. Have seen some people have 3-4 guys in the 1st round, then a big drop.

But when you compare this years class to next years class, you have Arch & Nico as tier 1. Then Ward & Sanders would be at the top of that 2nd tier mixed with Allar, Nuss, Sellers, and Klubnick. And Dart & Ewers are at the bottom of that 2nd tier.

quote:

---

Arch isn't coming out next year..

---

If true, then that increases the value of the top guys in this draft.

quote:

---

But when you compare this years class to next years class, you have Arch & Nico as tier 1.

---

This is very much subject to change. Arch is extremely talented yet has only started 2 regular season games. His potential draft stock has a ton riding on his on field performance as a full time starter at Texas. For all the hype & potential, Nico hasn't come close to playing up to the noise around him coming out of high school. Both Nico & the Vols have a lot riding how he plays this upcoming season.

quote:

---

2nd tier mixed with Allar, Nuss, Sellers, and Klubnick

---

Out of those 4, Nuss & Klubnik have the potential to make the biggest jump of all. They both will be throwing to two of the more talented WR corps in the nation. LSU may just end up having the deepest & most talented group but Clemson's will be right up there. Allar not so much & he will greatly miss Tyler Warren. Sellers has Nyckoles Harbor who is physical freak so that will help him.

All great points, which shows how overblown the statement is saying that this is a weak class.

Talking about what could happen next year with these rankings should be a quick reminder that around this time last year Ewers was considered a favorite to be the top QB this year. Now he’s projected from the bottom of the 1st (as the 4th QB off the board) or as a 3rd rounder (as the 4th or 5th guy)

quote:

---

Your takes are very negative and one sided.

---

He actually makes some valid & thoughtful points.

quote:

---

If CKM likes a QB in this draft and even trades up to get him you should be excited.

---

Both true & false. Just taking a QB to take one especially a project can set the franchise back even further than it is. Here's why. Carr is gone next offseason. The recent restructure basically confirmed that. So at a minimum, any QB drafted is possibly looking at being the starter in year 2 unless a veteran free agent is brought in to act as a bridge while this years draftee sits & develops.

The name that keeps getting brought up at #9 lately is Jaxson Dart yet Dart isn't a day one starting prospect & possibly isn't a year two starter either. In order to provide Dart with the best possible chance to be successful, he needs the Jordan Love treatment where he can sit develop for 2-3 seasons behind a veteran. That veteran won't be Carr though & if that veteran can't lead the team to wins, now you pushing the envelope & getting KM in hot seat territory.

It's true if there's one of those game changing day one starting QBs yet outside of Cam Ward, this draft is void of one of those type of prospects. Even with Ward as a rookie, he's gonna make some wow plays & throws but there's still going to be that rookie learning curve & mistakes. Shedeur Sanders even played under a former HC & offensive coordinator at Colorado but I feel like he shouldn't play at least half a season or none at all his rookie year.

quote:

---

Just think if Payton drafted Mahomes (outside the top 10) where’d we be?

---

We would be sitting lovely right now with Payton still HC & a couple of more Lombardis in the trophy case.

quote:

---

Your logic is flawed massively when it comes to drafting a QB in the first rd.

---

The make up of every draft is not the same though & this is common mistake fans make. It hasn't helped that several organizations over the past several drafts have seemed place lesser value on the position of having a top 10 draft selection.

quote:

---

 I mean Hurts was a 2nd rounder.

---

You are looking this take in the present. There were a lot of questions about Hurts accuracy & ability to read coverages even after showing improvements in one season at Oklahoma. Remember Hurts was BENCHED in the 2018 National Championship vs Georgia after struggling badly only for Tua Tagovailoa to come in the game on fire & lead Bama back to a victory in OT. A performance like that doesn't get forgotten very easily.

After aspect to ponder is just how successful would Hurts had he drafted by another franchise & placed in a totally different situation. The Eagles have hands down drafted unbelievably well over the past 4 years. They easily have the most talented roster in the league which has helped aid in Hurts development.

My guess is Dart goes in the second.