I think Banks starts at guard

Banks is your future. You didn't draft him to play Guard. Penning can sit the bench for all I care. You put Banks at LT, Fuaga back to RT and you are set for years to come.

LT - Banks
LG - Penning or trade for a 2nd rounder + a player.
C - McCoy
RG - Ruiz
RT - Fuaga

no, Banks at LT and Fuaga at RT and Penning either inside or on the bench gives us our best chance at a decent line.

quote:

---

I think Banks starts at guard

---

If Banks can't play LT, this is another disastrous pick.

If the Saints know he can't play LT and still drafted him at 9 it would be as bad a move as they have ever made.

To me, the reason this pick may end up helping the team significantly is that if he starts at LT and improves that position, you also improve (significantly) the RT position because that was always Fuaga's natural spot, and potentially significantly improves the guard position (Penning).

I actually agree. It’s not uncommon for a tackle to start at guard then move outside.

I think you let Penning, Brown and Fuaga all duke it out for starting tackle positions. One wins LT and one wins RT. If Penning stays at RT, Banks plays between Fuaga and McCoy and you have a dominant left side. If Penning earns a contract extension, you keep making them compete. If they let Penning walk in FA, you plug in Brown and draft a guard next year.

I don’t know if Penning can play guard. He might be too big and too slow. And we don’t have another guard. That’s why I think it might be better overall for Banks to play at guard one year then move outside next year.

Even if penning can't play lg, he's still valuable. The saints have oline injuries every year, and having a decent backup tackle is huge.

Perhaps. Because pairing Penning next to Banks seems less than ideal lol

We will have fresh eyes on the OL room this year. You got Paganetti who has worked under Stoutland in Philly. They made Becton (who is huge) into a guard, they moved Dickerson (who is huge) to guard, they morphed a rugby player into one of the best tackles in the game etc. Nugent has led guys around, Jahiri was a college tackle who moved to guard

I actually have trust in this staff to get creative and improve this unit. Because lord knows we’ve invested in it heavily

Trip mentioned a while back that he’s never, ever heard Penning at guard from anyone with the saints. He’s never played guard.

Maybe he can and do well but whatever he does honestly has zero impact on Banks or the team going forward. There’s only a slightly better than 0% chance he’s even on the team after 2025.

I’m more interested in whether or not Nick Saldiveri can play. Penning is a non factor.

He’s playing LT. You and the Saints need to stop thinking of creative ways to play people out of position. Sure, he can play G, but he is an LT and we need an LT.