- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Watched The Last Jedi. I don't get the vitriol.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 12:11 am
Posted on 7/4/18 at 12:11 am
I thought it was pretty damn entertaining.
Also didn't see the SJW shite everyone keeps bitching about. Maybe because I wasn't looking for it.
Oh well. Bring on the downvotes.
Also didn't see the SJW shite everyone keeps bitching about. Maybe because I wasn't looking for it.
Oh well. Bring on the downvotes.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 12:19 am to magildachunks
Get ready for sandy vaginas
Posted on 7/4/18 at 12:21 am to magildachunks
Did you see the part where Leia floated back onto the ship??
Posted on 7/4/18 at 12:31 am to magildachunks
quote:
Watched The Last Jedi.
Apparently not, based on the rest of your post.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 12:32 am to magildachunks
LINK
This video sums it up for me. The destroying of Luke Skywalker was bad enough, but if Johnson had just stuck with Abrams' story, and not made the preceding film irrelevant, it might have been good. Instead it was a movie of dead ends. Nothing really happened. Nothing mattered. TLJ was a beautiful film, with some amazing action. It was just hollow, dumb, and a slap in the face to people who remember the OT from their childhood. (Which is quite a few)
This video sums it up for me. The destroying of Luke Skywalker was bad enough, but if Johnson had just stuck with Abrams' story, and not made the preceding film irrelevant, it might have been good. Instead it was a movie of dead ends. Nothing really happened. Nothing mattered. TLJ was a beautiful film, with some amazing action. It was just hollow, dumb, and a slap in the face to people who remember the OT from their childhood. (Which is quite a few)
Posted on 7/4/18 at 1:15 am to magildachunks
quote:
Also didn't see the SJW shite everyone keeps bitching about. Maybe because I wasn't looking for it.
The entire sub plot was railing against capitalism, animal cruelty, and slavery.
They failed their mission but they still won because animals you guys lol
And honestly, that wasn’t why the movie was bad.
Horrible comedic timing, plot holes that make no sense, the complete lack of regard for build up in the previous film (if this weren’t the 8th episode in a 9 episode saga then maybe it would’ve been ok), a lackluster ending, Luke Skywalker went from believing the baddest Sith in the galaxy could still have good in him to trying to butcher a kid in his sleep because he “saw darkness in him”, give me a break.
Really, there’s more and we’ve discussed this shite ad nauseam and i really don’t care what you think. Just wanted you to know that the SJW shite had very little to do with this movie sucking.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 1:33 am to magildachunks
Someone, anyone explain to me why a fan of the OT should have an iota of respect for what they did to Luke Skywalker in this movie.
Abrams turning Han into a negligent, absent father/husband in TFA is a bit of a low blow but mostly in line with history of the character.
What RJ did to Luke is absolutely unforgivable. He lost his parents at birth, his caretakers as a teen, his mentor as soon as he learned his powers, his second mentor as soon as he was ready to complete his training, then his father all over again. So how is Luke rewarded for his on screen idealism and suffering? He forms a Jedi Academy (the one fricking thing every fan wanted to see) that is a catastrophic failure because *reasons* and he tries to murder his own family because *reasons* and all this happens off-screen and the info is only dumped on us at the tortured end of a tortured narrative because RJ wanted to knock fans down a few pegs and "subvert" expectations.
Abrams turning Han into a negligent, absent father/husband in TFA is a bit of a low blow but mostly in line with history of the character.
What RJ did to Luke is absolutely unforgivable. He lost his parents at birth, his caretakers as a teen, his mentor as soon as he learned his powers, his second mentor as soon as he was ready to complete his training, then his father all over again. So how is Luke rewarded for his on screen idealism and suffering? He forms a Jedi Academy (the one fricking thing every fan wanted to see) that is a catastrophic failure because *reasons* and he tries to murder his own family because *reasons* and all this happens off-screen and the info is only dumped on us at the tortured end of a tortured narrative because RJ wanted to knock fans down a few pegs and "subvert" expectations.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 1:45 am to magildachunks
quote:
I thought it was pretty damn entertaining.
Also didn't see the SJW shite everyone keeps bitching about. Maybe because I wasn't looking for it.
That was exactly my take. Just further enforces that the opinion on films of a lot of of this board is just people who think too highly of their opinions but really don't know what they're talking about.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 2:06 am to magildachunks
A graphic designer created a fake poster for those idiots that are trying to crowd fund a remake of The Last Jedi that perfectly mocks the folks crying SJW.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 2:08 am to magildachunks
You sure you didn't watch Return of the Jedi?
Posted on 7/4/18 at 2:32 am to magildachunks
Its not good from a Star Wars perspective.
These SJW agendas should be stuck in new movies, but then again that would limit whose eyes and ears they can get. What results is a trash movie.
These SJW agendas should be stuck in new movies, but then again that would limit whose eyes and ears they can get. What results is a trash movie.
This post was edited on 7/4/18 at 2:45 am
Posted on 7/4/18 at 3:37 am to magildachunks
Are all of the other threads on this same subject anchored? Or did we really need another one to reiterate the same things people have literally argued about hundreds of times for hundreds of thread pages?
This subject isn't just discussed, it has diverted the whole board into warring parties.
I do admit I have very strong feelings on the subject and don't think the people on the other side have a defensible point of view - but I am really ready for the subject to just go away for a while. Maybe then people will be able to go back to talking about interesting old movies or small projects they wanted to share.
This subject isn't just discussed, it has diverted the whole board into warring parties.
I do admit I have very strong feelings on the subject and don't think the people on the other side have a defensible point of view - but I am really ready for the subject to just go away for a while. Maybe then people will be able to go back to talking about interesting old movies or small projects they wanted to share.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 4:18 am to magildachunks
quote:
I thought it was pretty damn entertaining.
Yep, agree.
quote:
Also didn't see the SJW shite everyone keeps bitching about.
Me neither. Probably because you, like me, are not a pussy and a snowflake looking to be offended so you can bitch and moan.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 6:19 am to magildachunks
Haven’t seen it. Probably never will.
But I love the word “vitriol” so had to step in.
But I love the word “vitriol” so had to step in.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 7:02 am to magildachunks
It was ok if it were some standalone movie. It sucked as a Star Wars movie and it left a dead end as a second film in a trilogy. It also completely ruined some OT characters, mostly Luke.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 8:22 am to magildachunks
yay. another troll thread.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 8:35 am to magildachunks
I’ve watched the last Jedi a couple times in the last month. It is better rewatching it because the absolutely stupid parts of the movie are not shocking anymore. I like the parallels drawn to the old movies except having the opposite outcomes at every turn.
It’s still not good. It seems every time I watch floating in space Leia she is even further out from the ship than I thought previously. Luke’s whole storyline is crap. The pushing of the female leadership down our throats is even more obvious. Even my wife, who is a realistic feminist, thought this was absurd.
What’s silly is the framework was there for a cool movie in my opinion. It’s all the little details that they seemingly swung and missed hard on in between that makes the movie so dumb.
It’s still not good. It seems every time I watch floating in space Leia she is even further out from the ship than I thought previously. Luke’s whole storyline is crap. The pushing of the female leadership down our throats is even more obvious. Even my wife, who is a realistic feminist, thought this was absurd.
What’s silly is the framework was there for a cool movie in my opinion. It’s all the little details that they seemingly swung and missed hard on in between that makes the movie so dumb.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 8:43 am to magildachunks
I agree with the OP. The movie wasn’t groundbreaking, it was non stop action with very little plot. I did NOT like what they did with Luke, why have him force ghosting while fighting if he’s going to die anyway?
That said it was entertaining enough, I really didn’t see that much SJW stuff like everyone claimed. I mean the sub plot where they free the racehorses and stick it to the slaving society, is being against slavery SJW now?!?!?
Sure women were the leaders of the rebellion but why is that so hard to believe? There aren’t a lot of people in the rebellion, the main leader is Leia, a woman, why wouldn’t she have some other women helping her?
And honestly the movie made the woman leader (forgot her name) look pretty inept, she couldn’t control Poe.
Are people claiming Chewie not eating that chicken thing a shout out to vegans? It was comedic relief.
Y’all are way too sensitive
That said it was entertaining enough, I really didn’t see that much SJW stuff like everyone claimed. I mean the sub plot where they free the racehorses and stick it to the slaving society, is being against slavery SJW now?!?!?
Sure women were the leaders of the rebellion but why is that so hard to believe? There aren’t a lot of people in the rebellion, the main leader is Leia, a woman, why wouldn’t she have some other women helping her?
And honestly the movie made the woman leader (forgot her name) look pretty inept, she couldn’t control Poe.
Are people claiming Chewie not eating that chicken thing a shout out to vegans? It was comedic relief.
Y’all are way too sensitive
Posted on 7/4/18 at 9:05 am to magildachunks
Political stuff aside - since mentioning it instantly polarizes people - TLJ was still terrible, for reasons I have elaborated before, but shall do again since it is therapeutic for me:
-The First Order was played completely for laughs, thus removing any sense of threat when we see them on screen. Hux is a buffoon. Kylo Ren has already been beaten by Rey. Why is anyone afraid of them? Imagine if, in the climactic scene of Empire Strikes Back, Luke, having not completed his Jedi training with Yoda, nonetheless beat the crap out of Darth Vader. How excited would anyone have been for RotJ then? What would have been the point? The entire purpose of the second act of a story is to make it seem like the antagonist is too much for the protagonist to overcome and set up the final showdown. “Subverting expectations” by not doing that does leave your audience thinking, “Wow, I didn’t see that coming,” but not in a good way.
-The original trilogy had the benefit of no pre-existing backstory, so it was possible for them to be very vague with the setup. There is an Empire. They are bad and control the galaxy. At some point in the past there was a Republic that was good and which was defended by the Jedi, who were super good. Now there are Rebels fighting to restore the Republic, and the Jedi are (almost completely) gone. That’s all we needed. No specifics. Broad strokes got us where we needed to be to enjoy the story. The sequel trilogy, however, most assuredly does not have that luxury. We already know and love these characters. We know what they were fighting for and that they ultimately achieved their goals. These are not things that can be ignored, except that the sequel trilogy almost completely attempts to do that, and in the rare instances that it doesn’t, it shits all over what the original trilogy set up. Han Solo’s character arc from ANH to RotJ is that he learns to trust others and believe in something more than just himself. Except that apparently he didn’t, because he went right back to being a smuggler again when the final battle was done. Luke’s battle to restore the Jedi to the galaxy is the entire fricking point of the original trilogy. They didn’t call the third act “End of the Empire” or “Emperor’s Fall” or anything like that, they fricking named it Return of the Motherfricking Jedi. So it pisses off fans not a little when the sequel trilogy reveals that that victory was actually a failure, and Luke himself is not the awesome Jedi we saw him as at the end of RotMJ, but is instead a bitter old man who has decided that Jedi are stupid and the whole thing was a bad idea. And then Force Ghost Yoda shows up andinexplicably fricking agrees with him. If Yoda believed that the Jedi needed to die out, why go to all the trouble to train Luke as one in the original trilogy? Why not just show him the right way to hold a lightsaber and leave it at that?
-Now, TFA could afford to play a little coy with the events preceding it because it was the first act of a new story, and therefore its purpose was to set up some intriguing storylines that would be addressed in the second and third movies. We don’t know who Rey’s parents are because she herself doesn’t know. We don’t know who Snoke is or what he wants because (apparently) the Resistance doesn’t know either. We don’t know why the victory of the Rebellion turned out to be so incomplete and apparently inconsequential or why the restored Republic relies on a small band of freedom fighters rather than an actual fricking military because... well, look, just go with it, ok? But then TLJ comes along and completely shits all over those questions too. Want to know who Rey’s parents were? Well too bad, because you were apparently an idiot for even being curious in the first place. Want to know who Snoke is and what his goals are (i.e., THE ENTIRE frickING REASON ANY OF THIS IS HAPPENING IN THE FIRST PLACE)? The joke’s on you, motherfricker! TLJ makes such an obvious attempt to avoid normal, eons-old storytelling tropes that it basically laps itself and only succeeds in taking you out of what little story remains.
-And that isn’t even counting all the stupid little things in the movie, like the fact that in a galaxy with presumed trillions upon trillions of inhabitants, the fate of them all is being decided by two groups with about five ships and a few hundred people each. Seriously, if the First Order’s rule is so lax that only a few hundred people out of trillions can be bothered to stand up to it, can it really be that bad? And then there is the stupid “speed limit in space” ridiculousness, the fact that the Resistance “wins” at the end by running away so effectively that the First Order basically gives up, Finn’s big heroic moment being him hitting a woman in the back, the entire Finn-Rose-Poe subplot that ends up having no point and going nowhere... I could go on.
TLJ is a bad movie by any standard. One need not inject politics into things to make that point.
-The First Order was played completely for laughs, thus removing any sense of threat when we see them on screen. Hux is a buffoon. Kylo Ren has already been beaten by Rey. Why is anyone afraid of them? Imagine if, in the climactic scene of Empire Strikes Back, Luke, having not completed his Jedi training with Yoda, nonetheless beat the crap out of Darth Vader. How excited would anyone have been for RotJ then? What would have been the point? The entire purpose of the second act of a story is to make it seem like the antagonist is too much for the protagonist to overcome and set up the final showdown. “Subverting expectations” by not doing that does leave your audience thinking, “Wow, I didn’t see that coming,” but not in a good way.
-The original trilogy had the benefit of no pre-existing backstory, so it was possible for them to be very vague with the setup. There is an Empire. They are bad and control the galaxy. At some point in the past there was a Republic that was good and which was defended by the Jedi, who were super good. Now there are Rebels fighting to restore the Republic, and the Jedi are (almost completely) gone. That’s all we needed. No specifics. Broad strokes got us where we needed to be to enjoy the story. The sequel trilogy, however, most assuredly does not have that luxury. We already know and love these characters. We know what they were fighting for and that they ultimately achieved their goals. These are not things that can be ignored, except that the sequel trilogy almost completely attempts to do that, and in the rare instances that it doesn’t, it shits all over what the original trilogy set up. Han Solo’s character arc from ANH to RotJ is that he learns to trust others and believe in something more than just himself. Except that apparently he didn’t, because he went right back to being a smuggler again when the final battle was done. Luke’s battle to restore the Jedi to the galaxy is the entire fricking point of the original trilogy. They didn’t call the third act “End of the Empire” or “Emperor’s Fall” or anything like that, they fricking named it Return of the Motherfricking Jedi. So it pisses off fans not a little when the sequel trilogy reveals that that victory was actually a failure, and Luke himself is not the awesome Jedi we saw him as at the end of RotMJ, but is instead a bitter old man who has decided that Jedi are stupid and the whole thing was a bad idea. And then Force Ghost Yoda shows up andinexplicably fricking agrees with him. If Yoda believed that the Jedi needed to die out, why go to all the trouble to train Luke as one in the original trilogy? Why not just show him the right way to hold a lightsaber and leave it at that?
-Now, TFA could afford to play a little coy with the events preceding it because it was the first act of a new story, and therefore its purpose was to set up some intriguing storylines that would be addressed in the second and third movies. We don’t know who Rey’s parents are because she herself doesn’t know. We don’t know who Snoke is or what he wants because (apparently) the Resistance doesn’t know either. We don’t know why the victory of the Rebellion turned out to be so incomplete and apparently inconsequential or why the restored Republic relies on a small band of freedom fighters rather than an actual fricking military because... well, look, just go with it, ok? But then TLJ comes along and completely shits all over those questions too. Want to know who Rey’s parents were? Well too bad, because you were apparently an idiot for even being curious in the first place. Want to know who Snoke is and what his goals are (i.e., THE ENTIRE frickING REASON ANY OF THIS IS HAPPENING IN THE FIRST PLACE)? The joke’s on you, motherfricker! TLJ makes such an obvious attempt to avoid normal, eons-old storytelling tropes that it basically laps itself and only succeeds in taking you out of what little story remains.
-And that isn’t even counting all the stupid little things in the movie, like the fact that in a galaxy with presumed trillions upon trillions of inhabitants, the fate of them all is being decided by two groups with about five ships and a few hundred people each. Seriously, if the First Order’s rule is so lax that only a few hundred people out of trillions can be bothered to stand up to it, can it really be that bad? And then there is the stupid “speed limit in space” ridiculousness, the fact that the Resistance “wins” at the end by running away so effectively that the First Order basically gives up, Finn’s big heroic moment being him hitting a woman in the back, the entire Finn-Rose-Poe subplot that ends up having no point and going nowhere... I could go on.
TLJ is a bad movie by any standard. One need not inject politics into things to make that point.
Posted on 7/4/18 at 9:34 am to magildachunks
The people who liked TLJ are likely the same people who like pure action movies.
Both have no substance or soul, just flashy Wooow special effects.
Both have no substance or soul, just flashy Wooow special effects.
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News