re: UPDATE: Idaho Murders Thread (Links inside)

quote:

---

But it seems he knew the house so it would make some sense that he had been there before.

---

He could have use the same real-estate video we used a few pages back to get a feel for the layout and he should know who lived in each room by his stalking observations. He may have crashed parties there as well. I dont think he just freeballed this crime, he planned it and his plan was shite and I hope he rots in hell for it.

No use arguing with this kind of stupidity.

quote:

---

Unfortunately it’s stupidly that has derailed this thread. As soon as it was revealed she saw the killer it all became about how drunk or high was this girl. What purpose does it serve to continue to throw her under the bus as a potentially drunken or chemically incapacitated witness?

---

It seems unfair to judge her without knowing exactly what went down. People can speculate, but don't really see the point without knowing more.

quote:

---

was reported he was a loner in college with a high IQ and studied criminology and BTK's killings. It seems logical and

---

Interesting that BTK's first killings happen to also be 4 people.

quote:

---

quote:

quote:

---

They have so much other evidence that there's no reason to ask Dylan to testify that the person she saw is the defendant. Too easy for the defense to pick apart that testimony.

---

Exactly why the defense will call her if the prosecution doesn't.

---

If the prosecution only has someone who can point out build and eye brows, provide some context with some things she heard along with a general after 4am murder timeframe, and the possible exit killer used this shouldn’t even be going to trial.

She doesn’t specifically place him there. She didn’t even witness murders, see blood, or knife that we know of. She just adds weight to other evidence being used to calculate timeframe of murders with what she heard and that a male with similar build and eyebrows to defendant was seen in house during this time frame heading towards the back door and also might have earlier made a creepy comment about being there to help (which she can’t directly tie to this guy). She heard less of what could be described as violence than the security cam next door.

Without her they know all 4 were murdered by a knife. His DNA was on knife sheath. They know Xana was alive at 4am and likely using TikTok later. At 4:17am they have dog barking, voices/wimper followed by a thud on a neighbor security cam 50 ft away from her bedroom. They have videos of car coming and going. They know he has similar car including not having front license plate at time of murders matching some videos. They know his travel with phone on and when phone was turned off and back on.

Before anything police may learn after his arrest the biggest problem defense has right now is minimizing his dna on sheath as possibly left on it before that night or find some other technicality to remove entirely and then find a way to reasonably push out time of death past 4:20am then white car doesn’t matter as much nor do
sounds on neighbor’s security cam and the farther out from 4:20am the less the timeframe of his phone being off matters.

If these happen and prosecutor still decides to continue relying on Dylan for time of murders and for seeing someone in house who fits build and eyebrows of defendant the defense will tear her apart during cross, but the defense has a lot of work before this would be effective overall (& hopefully a lot more work for them is found with new evidence).

The only way the defense calls her to the stand themselves would be to try to create doubt by pinning the murders on her, but nothing by itself attributed to Dylan in affidavit would achieve this or even come close. I also don’t think using being scared and showing poor judgment in waiting to call cops to paint her as the murderer would play well to jury.

That’s an awfully angry response to someone saying enough is enough. We don’t need to keep tossing this girl under the bus. Besides if some of you will stfu and read instead of continuing to chase her non existent tox report, you’ll find quite a few reasonable explanations as to her behavior posted in this thread. They just been buried by the “sleuths” trying to determine with absolute specificity the chemical composition of her blood at 4am.

quote:

---

Most people are in disbelief over how she could behave as she did given the situation.

---

Because they're not thinking.

It was a party house, Her fear was probably something she realized after the fact. At the time she probably wasn't too concerned.

Memories change after the fact. I imagine she saw the guy, the guy didn't see her and she didn't think too much of it at the time.

“I suspect he was in that house before”

I read that his phone had pinged the tower in the area of the house at least 12 times between Aug 12th and Nov 13 th during the late evening or early morning hours.
He definitely was stalking at least one of the girls.
I think it was likely he had found the house empty a time or two,doors probably unlocked so he walks in and takes a tour ,familiarizing himself with the layout.

quote:

---

Why is this line of questioning even a discussion? The police were called and discovered a quadruple homicide. They didn’t turn around and then make the roommates do a field sobriety test or submit blood samples for a toxicology report. To even suggest they did is asinine. Instead of speculating at the possibility of her toxicology report being used against her in court, just stop. There is no toxicology report for the surviving roommates. There wasn’t a need for one.

---

I didn’t say a toxicology report had already been administered. Not once. I inferred that if the girl was fricked up, the defense team would utilize that information. And that’s only if that information would be attainable.

I don’t thing anyone is blaming this girl. I certainly am not. I’m looking at this particular moment with legal prosecution vs. defense lenses. And I hate that it’s going to ruin the girl even further.

I don’t think she went back to sleep. Probably froze up some type of trauma Induced dissociation.